CIT in Finance Explained: Why Collective Investment Trusts Are the Future of Retirement Investing in 2025

by

Understanding CITs (Collective Investment Trusts)

If you’re looking into retirement options or managing institutional investments, you might have come across CITs, or Collective Investment Trusts. So, what are they? A CIT is an investment fund that pools money together much like a mutual fund. However, it’s built for institutions such as retirement funds.

In the United States, CITs have grown more popular in recent years. They’ve gained traction among 401(k) plans and defined benefit plans. Their appeal lies in lower costs adaptable structures, and tax benefits making them a smart choice for seasoned investors.

A Quick Look at CITs’ History in the U.S.

CITs started in 1927 becoming some of the first pooled investment options in the U.S. Banks created them to handle assets in trusts more . As time went on, CITs grew to help qualified retirement plans under ERISA giving investors a more affordable way to combine funds.

In the past few decades, changes in regulations and increased interest in low-cost and adaptable investment choices have contributed to their growth in the U.S. market.

How a CIT Works

A Collective Investment Trust works like a trust fund managed by a bank or trust company. Retirement plans and similar investors combine their money in these trusts, which follow a specific investment plan.

CITs, unlike mutual funds, don’t need to register with the SEC as long as they meet certain rules. Since they aren’t available to the public, their costs to operate end up lower.

How CITs Differ from Mutual Funds

Regulation

The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) and state banking regulators oversee CITs, while the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) regulates mutual funds.

Fee Structure

CITs come with lower fees since they don’t need to meet some SEC rules such as filing detailed prospectuses or sharing regular public reports.

Investment Strategy and Flexibility

Fund managers for CITs, which are designed for institutional clients often get more freedom to adjust investment strategies. This allows them to offer more options than mutual funds.

How Does a CIT Work?

When a retirement plan puts money into a CIT, its funds are merged with other plans to form a bigger investment pool. A professional manager handles the assets based on the trust’s planned investment strategy.

Participants take on profits, losses, and expenses in line with how much they have invested.

Why CITs Can Benefit Investors

Lower Costs

CITs do not need to meet several SEC rules so they have cheaper management fees and operate at a lower expense compared to mutual funds.

More Tailored Options

Plan sponsors often work out terms and set investment rules with the trust manager creating a more flexible and customized investment strategy.

Tax Benefits

CITs avoid double taxation, which might result in better tax savings when compared to other pooled investment options.

Challenges and Risks of CITs

Although CITs provide a lot of benefits, they also come with some risks.

  • Less transparency when compared to public mutual funds.
  • Limited availability, open to certain eligible plans.
  • Reduced liquidity might apply sometimes.

Investors need to think about these points to decide if a CIT suits their needs.

Different Types of CITs

Equity-Focused CITs

These invest in stocks aiming to grow capital over time.

Fixed Income CITs

These concentrate on bonds and other debt-related assets. Their primary goal is to provide a constant income stream.

Target Date CITs

These shift their asset strategy as investors near retirement age moving toward safer options .

Who Can Put Money Into a CIT?

qualified retirement plans like 401(k), pension plans, and certain non-profit organization plans can put funds into CITs. These funds are off-limits to everyday individual investors.

Who Oversees CITs?

CITs do not fall under SEC authority, but they come under the watch of several regulators such as:

  • Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC)
  • Internal Revenue Service (IRS)
  • State banking commissions

Plans that use CITs must also meet ERISA requirements.

How CITs Are Priced and Valued

CITs use the same Net Asset Value formula as mutual funds to set their prices. But unlike mutual funds that price for everyone to see many CITs adjust their NAVs , like once a month or every three months.

CITs or ETFs: What’s the Right Choice for You?

Both CITs and ETFs give you access to a mix of investments and are managed by professionals. Still, they have some big differences:

FeatureCITETFAccessInstitutions onlyAnyoneRegulated byOCC/IRSSECTradingNot traded during the dayTraded anytime on exchangesFeesLower costsA bit higher

Making your choice depends on whether you’re part of an institution or just an everyday investor.

Leading Companies Providing CITs in the USA

Some top firms include:

  • Fidelity Investments
  • Vanguard Group
  • Northern Trust
  • Wells Fargo
  • T. Rowe Price

These organizations provide numerous CITs designed to match varying investment approaches and objectives.

What Lies Ahead for Collective Investment Trusts

With changes in the financial world, Collective Investment Trusts (CITs) are becoming more popular. Trends point to their ongoing growth in retirement plans offered by employers.

Their rise comes down to several key factors:

  • Lower Costs: CITs provide a cheaper option as investors focus more on reducing expenses.
  • Flexibility: Retirement plans aim to address specific needs, and CITs allow adjustments to achieve that.
  • Tech Adoption: New fintech tools make CITs easier to use, clearer to understand, and simpler to manage.

Some experts believe CITs might soon hold more 401(k) plan assets than mutual funds.

Tips To Choose a CIT

Evaluate the Manager’s Experience

Study the trust manager’s past performance, approach to management, and how they are viewed in the industry. Find managers who deliver results better than their benchmarks.

Learn About the Investment Goal

Each CIT serves a particular purpose. It might focus on growth generating income, or keeping capital safe. Make sure its goal matches what your plan needs.

Look Into the Fees

Do not stop at checking the management fee. Dig deeper to identify any extra costs like admin fees, custody charges, or transaction expenses to get a clear picture of the actual total cost.

Widespread Misunderstandings About CITs

Many myths exist around CITs that should be cleared up:

  • Myth 1: CITs are more dangerous than mutual funds.

    ➔ Truth: The level of risk depends on how the assets are managed and the specific strategy used, not the type of investment.

  • Myth 2: CITs don’t offer clarity.

    ➔ Truth: CITs may not share as much information with the public as mutual funds do. However most trusted managers still send detailed updates to investors often.

  • Myth 3: big retirement plans can use CITs.

    ➔ Truth: CITs are now available to many mid-sized plans through shared accounts.

Case Study: How Retirement Plans Benefitted from CITs

ABC Corporation, a tech company in California, changed its 401(k) investment choices in 2022. They switched from traditional mutual funds to CITs.

What happened next?

  • Participants paid 0.35% less in fees on average.
  • More employees chose higher-risk, growth-focused funds growing by 22%.
  • Employers became much happier with how the plan performed.

This change didn’t just cut costs. It also got employees more involved in managing their retirement savings.

FAQs About CITs in Finance

1. Can you explain what a CIT is in easy language?

A Collective Investment Trust (CIT) is a type of pooled fund that banks or trust companies manage. Retirement plans often use them to lower costs and tailor investment approaches.

2. Are CITs better than mutual funds?

Most institutional investors would say yes. CITs often have lower fees, more flexibility, and allow for customization, which sets them apart from mutual funds.

3. Can individual investors buy CITs?

No, they can’t. CITs are open to qualified institutional buyers like employer retirement plans. They aren’t meant for the general public.

4. How do CITs save costs for investors?

Since CITs don’t have to register with the SEC or follow public disclosure rules, they skip over several regulatory expenses. Investors benefit from this by paying lower fees.

5. Are CITs regulated?

Yes, they are. Even though the SEC doesn’t oversee them, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) and the IRS monitor them. These regulations ensure CITs stay compliant with legal standards.

6. How are CIT prices determined?

CIT pricing relies on Net Asset Value (NAV). Depending on how the plan is set up, the NAV can be calculated , monthly, or sometimes quarterly.

7. What should I think about when picking a CIT?

Look into the manager’s record, expenses, goals of the investment, and how clear their reporting is before deciding.

Why are CITs becoming a bigger deal in retirement plans?

People like CITs because they cost less, can be tailored, and provide high-level investment management. This makes them a strong fit for modern 401(k) plans.

Are CITs the future of institutional investing?

As the financial world shifts toward cutting costs, personalizing options, and earning better returns, Collective Investment Trusts (CITs) stand out as a top choice for retirement plans and institutional investors.

Their benefits include lower fees flexible structures, and strong investment strategies. These qualities make them very attractive when you compare them to standard mutual funds and ETFs.

Atharv Banna
Latest posts by Atharv Banna (see all)

Leave a Comment